Reflections on Richard Shusterman's Dewey

James Scott Johnston

Presumably, when Richard Shusterman talks of an aesthetic experience, he has in mind the sort of experience that connotes an immediate, qualitative whole John Dewey calls “consummatory” in Art as Experience. Problematically though, with Dewey, he has the urge to tell us what is primary in an experience. Making liberal use of Dewey’s own statements from Art as Experience Shusterman tells us it is just the “memorable and ultimately satisfying episode of living, one that stands out from the humdrum flow of life as “an experience by its “internal integration and fulfillment” reaching through a developing organization of meanings and energies which affords a “satisfying emotional quality” of some sort.1 Also, “For there seems, after all, to be something autonomous about art’s value, something about its own good for which we pursue them [sic] as ends in themselves rather than means to other goods in other practices. That something is an aesthetic experience. For the immediate, absorbing satisfaction of such experience makes it incontestably an end in itself” (PA, 46-47).